Rahul Gandhi Naravane memoir controversy dominated proceedings in the Lok Sabha on Monday after the Congress leader clarified that his remarks on the 2020 China border clash were based on the perspective of former Army Chief General (retd) M M Naravane, not his personal views. The Leader of the Opposition said he was merely citing references from Naravane’s unpublished memoir, which he claimed was being withheld from publication, sparking sharp exchanges with the government and disruptions in the House.
Speaking amid an uproar, the Rae Bareilly MP said his comments were rooted in what the former Army Chief had written about the government’s handling of the standoff with China. The issue quickly escalated into a political confrontation, with senior BJP leaders accusing Gandhi of misleading Parliament.
Gandhi distances himself from remarks, cites Naravane’s book
Clarifying his position, Rahul Gandhi said the statements he referred to were drawn from the former Army Chief’s own account.
“This is not me, this is what the Army Chief (former) has written in a book,” Gandhi was quoted.
He added that the memoir was yet to be published and described it as “languishing,” questioning why the government appeared uncomfortable with its contents.
Claims of fear over former Army Chief’s perspective
Gandhi questioned the Centre’s alleged reluctance to allow the book’s publication, suggesting it contained uncomfortable truths.
“Why are they so scared of the Army Chief’s perspective? Why are they so scared of what the Army Chief has to say?” he asked.
According to the Congress leader, the memoir offers significant insights into the role of the political leadership during the 2020 border crisis, including references to Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Defence Minister Rajnath Singh.
Lok Sabha disrupted over China border clash references
The controversy intensified after Gandhi repeatedly attempted to cite a magazine report based on the unpublished manuscript while questioning the government’s handling of the China border standoff. This led to loud protests, with Defence Minister Rajnath Singh, Home Minister Amit Shah and other BJP members accusing him of distorting facts and misleading the House.
Also read: Balochistan attacks leave over 190 dead as Pakistan hunts militants, India denies involvement
Allegations of political leadership letting the Army down
Gandhi maintained that the former Army Chief had clearly written about the Prime Minister and the Defence Minister in his memoir, excerpts of which he was quoting. He claimed the book would reveal “something about the Army and how it was let down by the political leadership of the country.”
He further alleged that he was being prevented from speaking because the government feared public scrutiny.
“If it comes out, the reality of Narendra Modi and Rajnath Singh will be revealed to the people,” Gandhi said, adding a sharp reference to the Prime Minister’s much-used “56-inch chest” remark during the standoff with China.